Michigan has officially broken the Ohio State football program, and only one thing can fix it

For decades, the rivalry between Michigan and Ohio State has been one of college football’s defining features. Known simply as “The Game,” this annual clash has shaped seasons, determined championships, and forged legends. But in recent years, the rivalry has taken on a new dynamic: Michigan has seized control.

After years of dominance by the Buckeyes, the Wolverines under Jim Harbaugh have not only turned the tide but have seemingly broken the Ohio State football program in ways few could have imagined. Three consecutive victories by Michigan, including convincing wins in 2021, 2022, and now 2023, have left Ohio State fans and analysts alike wondering: what went wrong? And more importantly, what can be done to fix it?

The Decline of Ohio State’s Dominance

Ohio State once seemed invincible in this rivalry, winning 17 of 19 matchups from 2001 to 2019. The Buckeyes boasted high-powered offenses, elite recruiting classes, and a swagger that made them the envy of college football. However, Michigan’s recent success has exposed vulnerabilities within Ohio State’s program.

The Wolverines have redefined their identity under Harbaugh, focusing on physicality, discipline, and a punishing ground game. This formula has allowed Michigan to outmuscle Ohio State, whose defenses have struggled to match up with Michigan’s relentless running attack and precision. In 2023, Michigan’s ability to control the line of scrimmage and dictate the pace of the game underscored a growing gap in toughness and preparation between the two programs.

Offensively, Ohio State’s once-dominant passing game has looked out of sync in key moments against Michigan. While the Buckeyes still produce elite quarterbacks and wide receivers, their inability to impose their will on the ground or protect their quarterbacks in high-pressure situations has been glaring.

The Fallout

The fallout for Ohio State has been immediate and widespread. Head coach Ryan Day, who once seemed like the perfect successor to Urban Meyer, is now under intense scrutiny. Despite a stellar overall record, his failure to beat Michigan in three straight years has raised questions about his ability to navigate the program through its most critical game.

Recruiting momentum has also shifted. Michigan’s success has resonated with recruits who value the Wolverines’ physical style and the resurgence of their national profile. Ohio State, meanwhile, has struggled to convince prospects that their program is still the dominant force in the Big Ten.

Perhaps most concerning for Ohio State fans is the psychological toll. Michigan has not just beaten Ohio State; it has broken the Buckeyes’ aura of invincibility. Players and fans alike seem to approach “The Game” with a sense of dread rather than confidence—a stark contrast to the swagger of previous eras.

The Only Solution: A Culture Reset

For Ohio State to reclaim its place atop the rivalry, a fundamental culture reset is needed. This goes beyond tactical adjustments or personnel changes. The Buckeyes need to rediscover their identity as a program that thrives on toughness, resilience, and a relentless commitment to excellence.

1. Reinvest in Physicality: Ohio State must reestablish dominance in the trenches. Recruiting and developing offensive and defensive linemen who can win against Michigan’s physical style is essential.
2. Reevaluate Coaching Strategies: Ryan Day must embrace the pressure of “The Game” and adapt his approach. This may involve delegating defensive responsibilities to proven experts or embracing a more balanced offensive philosophy.
3. Instill a Mental Edge: The rivalry isn’t just won on the field—it’s won in the mind. Ohio State needs leaders who can inspire confidence and urgency within the locker room, ensuring that players view Michigan as a challenge to conquer rather than a hurdle to fear.
4. Leverage Rivalry Energy: Rivalries are cyclical, and Ohio State can use its current struggles as fuel for a comeback. Leaning into the rivalry’s stakes and fostering an underdog mentality could help reignite the fire within the program.

The Road Ahead

For Ohio State fans, the current state of affairs is painful. Watching Michigan celebrate three consecutive victories feels like a nightmare that won’t end. But the rivalry is far from over. The Buckeyes have the resources, talent, and history to mount a comeback—if they’re willing to do the hard work required to adapt.

Ultimately, Ohio State’s ability to fix what Michigan has broken will determine not just the future of “The Game,” but the trajectory of the entire Big Ten and national college football landscape. For now, the ball is firmly in Michigan’s court, and the Buckeyes are left searching for answers.